Our Guide to the Tastiest Ice Cream Hawley, PA, Has to Offer

I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream. No matter how old you are, there is nothing like enjoying a creamy scoop of ice cream on a hot summer day. If you’re looking for the best ice cream Hawley, PA, we have a few recommendations. From handmade hard ice cream to soft-serve and gelato, we know the best spots to treat yourself and the whole family!

If you’re looking for ideas on other fun things to do in our area, consider downloading our free Delaware Highlands Vacation Guide. While you might be searching for ice cream Hawley, PA, you’ll find other fun places you’ll want to visit, upcoming events to attend, and outdoor recreation you shouldn’t miss. Our free guide will make planning your vacation much easier and stress-free.

For Ice Cream in Hawley, PA, Try One of These Local Favorites

Coutts Ice Cream

Coutts Ice Cream is a family-owned and operated business that has been serving handcrafted ice cream in Hawley since 2010. They originally started selling homemade ice cream at the Paupack Blueberry Farm, where you can still find them today! The Paupack Blueberry Farm on Gumbletown Road is a great local place to pick your own blueberries from July to September! In addition to making premium ice cream, they also make and sell homemade fudge, dairy-free gelato, and soft-serve. If you’re not an ice cream fan but still love a frozen treat, try their fruit icee in flavors like watermelon, strawberry, or grape. Their season usually runs from April-September.

Gresham’s Ice Cream Shoppe

Gresham’s Ice Cream Shoppe serves Hershey’s hard ice cream, soft-serve, and Dole soft-serve. They also have a menu of hot dogs, soft pretzels, and other snack items. In season, their hours are usually from noon to 9:00 p.m.

Dairy Twist

Dairy Twist is another popular ice cream spot. They can be found near Lake Wallenpaupack and serve a variety of different treats. Most visitors come to try their soft-serve, which is available in over 24 flavors, but they also offer hard ice cream with toppings for an extra special treat.

Have a Relaxing Getaway Here at The Settlers Inn

Sometimes a getaway is all you need to feel refreshed for a new week. Because our Inn is in the Lake Region of the Pocono Mountains, we’re close to plenty of outdoor recreation to explore. The Settlers Inn is home to 23 guest rooms with four different types. Here at the Inn, we are proud to be a part of the Green Lodging program. With each reservation, a $2 donation goes towards the Conservancy to protect the lands and water of the Upper Delaware Region.

We are also proud to offer our guests an award-winning farm-to-table restaurant right here on the property. Executive Chef Ben Sutter creates each menu with local and seasonal ingredients. You will find creative menu items like butternut squash soup, winter root veg risotto, and jackfruit meatballs. Speaking of delicious ice cream in Hawley, PA, our dessert menu is known to have incredible chocolate and vanilla ice cream and a sorbet trio.

Finally, let us pamper you on your next trip to the Pocono Mountains. We offer guests many specials throughout the year so be sure to inquire when booking your reservation.